Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cellular images can help prioritize compounds for further testing, but useful predictions may reflect information already captured by chemical structure or cell count. We examined whether morphology added predictive value beyond both comparators and whether that value transferred across experimental settings. Using EU-OPENSCREEN profiles, we developed models in three HepG2 laboratories and evaluated them in a fourth laboratory. Evaluation excluded compounds and chemical scaffolds represented in our preceding analyses. Two of 12 Tox21 endpoints met prespecified sample requirements: antioxidant-response-element activity and mitochondrial-membrane-potential activity. Their test sets contained 85 and 95 compounds, respectively, representing 117 distinct compounds overall. We then compared predictions for the same compounds using HepG2 and U2OS profiles. Adding morphology to structure and segmented-object count improved the logistic-regression model's mean Brier score by 0.0335 (95% CI: 0.0082–0.0628). The antioxidant-response estimate remained uncertain; mitochondrial-activity gains were positive in both model families. The random-forest mean gain was smaller and its interval included zero. Morphology alone and an adapted published fusion method ranked mitochondrial activity better than the selected fusion. In the paired cellular-context comparison, gains decreased by 0.0534 and 0.0357, respectively, and became slightly negative in U2OS. A laboratory-consistency selection rule made the same decisions as a simpler interval rule in the real tasks and all 2,000 simulations. This retrospective comparison supports additional predictive value in the evaluated HepG2 setting, not a generally superior fusion method. Its empirical emphasis followed a null primary comparison between selection rules. Prospective target-context evaluation is needed before using these gains to guide preclinical screening.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yi¹ et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: