Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
School belonging is a subjective dimension of adolescent psychosocial adjustment. Immigrant generation may mark different opportunities for social connection and experiences of acculturation, whose associations with belonging may depend on context. We compare PISA-defined native, second-generation, and first-generation students in Hong Kong (China), Singapore, and Macao (China), using PISA 2022 complete-case samples of 5,155, 6,357, and 4,183 students. System-specific weighted regressions adjust for sex, age, and socioeconomic status; inference uses 80 Fay-BRR replicate weights. The first-generation versus native coefficient is 0.100 in Hong Kong (95% CI [0.009, 0.190]) and 0.089 in Macao ([0.025, 0.153]); the second-generation coefficient is 0.082 in Singapore ([0.008, 0.155]). These estimates are small relative to within-group variation. Across the six primary generation-versus-native comparisons, Holm-adjusted p-values are .149, .040, and .149, respectively. Direct first-minus-second-generation contrasts have intervals spanning zero in all three systems. A joint cross-system test does not establish heterogeneous generation associations (p = .482), nor does it prove the associations equivalent. Excluded students differ from included students on observed characteristics, especially in Hong Kong; response-propensity weighting based on sex and age changes estimates little but cannot resolve unobserved selection. These findings qualify a general immigrant-disadvantage expectation for adolescent school belonging, while leaving the relational and acculturative processes underlying the associations unresolved. PISA categories describe birthplace patterns, not citizenship or legal status.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yuming Zhou (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: