Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Population aging and digitalization are advancing together across East Asia, yet older adults in comparable urban settings develop contrasting digital survival strategies. Using a most-similar-systems design, this exploratory comparative case study examines why older adults in Beijing and Tokyo, despite similar internet penetration and aging rates, differ in digital payments, platform participation, and cash retention. Drawing on secondary data from China (N = 6,117) and Japan (N = 510), we introduce a two-dimensional framework of adoption depth × adoption agency as a fourth level of the digital divide. Beijing exhibits high depth but low agency: cash as primary payment rises from 24.0% (ages 50–59) to 55.9% (60+; odds ratio [OR] = 4.01; Cohen’s h = 0.67), and 35.4% of online orders are placed by children. Tokyo exhibits medium depth but high agency: cash use is nearly age-flat (OR = 1.37; h = 0.15), over 90% of older women manage loyalty points, and daily cash use in the 60s fell from 75% to 34% (2018–2024). The between-city age-gradient ratio is approximately 22-fold (a descriptive ratio, not a statistical estimate). We interpret this divergence not as individual deficit but as contrasting ecosystem structures: algorithmic reliance in Beijing versus cash-centered resistance in Tokyo. Findings are generative rather than causal.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
于江波 et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: