Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Paper 1 said that the establishment of a discipline draws divisions, and that divisions leave remainders. This paper says that once fields are divided, every discipline has premises it needs in order to run which its current internal procedures cannot settle without circularity, such as the threshold of "significance" in statistics. These premises must always be held steady, so the position that holds them cannot be empty; what holds them can be standards, instruments, classifications, indicators, training and default parameters (S9). The position that publicly questions these premises, however, can be empty; when the questioning position is empty, the setting position runs all the same, and that is enough to show the two positions are not one (S10). The paper first defines "scope of warrant" (S11), then gives four conditions for occupying the questioning position: jurisdiction, right of response, right of review, independence; the four are conjunctive, and each can fail on its own (S12). Each case is recorded under three items, which are not steps in a progression: whether the position is occupied; whether questioning took place, and whether the answer reached the matter questioned; what the outcome is, and whether it entered everyday procedure (S13). That a discipline's own foundational research and revision working groups touch a premise does not mean they occupy the questioning position; this is decided by the three records (S14). Six propositions in all (S9 to S14), stated at the end of each section and listed together at the end. 第一篇说,学科的建制作出划分,划分留下余项。这一篇说,分了科以后,每一门学科都有运行所需,又不能由它现行的内部程序无循环地裁定的前提,比如统计学里那条"显著"的门槛。这些前提总要被稳定下来,所以稳住它们的位置不能空;稳住它们的,可以是标准,仪器,分类,指标,训练与默认的参数(S9)。对这些前提作公开追问的位置,却可以空着;追问的位置空着时,设定的位置照样运行,这就足以说明两个位置不是同一个(S10)。这一篇先给"保证范围"一个定义(S11),再给占据追问位置的四条件:辖域,回应权,复审权,独立性,四条合取,逐条可以不满足(S12)。每一个案例记三项,不作递进:占据了没有;追问开展了没有,答到了没有;结论是什么,进没进日常的程序(S13)。学科自己的基础研究与修订工作组触及了前提,不等于占据了追问的位置,要按这三项记录判(S14)。全篇六条(S9 至 S14),各节末写出,篇末合列。 Related works(3) # Identifier Title 1 10.5281/zenodo.23271324 Open to Questioning (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 6) 2 10.5281/zenodo.24177508 What a Discipline Is Not (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Prequel) 3 10.5281/zenodo.24177748 Parochialism (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 1)
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Han Qin (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: