Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The selective activation of strong aliphatic C–H bonds remains a fundamental challenge in catalysis due to their high bond dissociation energies and limited chemical differentiation. In biological systems, nonheme FeIV=O intermediates serve as powerful oxidants, enabling challenging C–H transformations such as L-arginine oxidation in ethylene-forming enzymes (EFEs). Here, we investigate how metal substitution modulates the structure, electronic configuration, and reactivity of the EFE active site by replacing iron with manganese and cobalt. Extensive molecular dynamics simulations demonstrate that all three metals maintain stable coordination within the protein matrix, while revealing a conserved hydrogen-bonding network that generates strong, oriented local electric fields along the M=O axis. Quantitative LEF analysis identifies Arg171 as a dominant electrostatic contributor that elongates the M=O bond and stabilizes high-spin configurations across all variants. Hybrid QM/MM calculations uncover pronounced metaldependent differences in C–H activation barriers, with CoIV=O exhibiting the lowest barrier, followed by MnIV=O and FeIV=O. Multireference CASSCF computations reveal that these trends originate from symmetry-breaking orbital bifurcation within the M=O unit, leading to variable degrees of oxyl radical (M–O•) character. Importantly, C–H activation proceeds via a protein-enforced π-channel hydrogen-atom transfer mechanism in all cases, independent of metal identity or formal spin state. Together, these results establish oxyl radical character, regulated by protein electrostatics and metal-dependent electronic flexibility, as the primary determinant of reactivity in EFE-like systems, offering general design principles for biomimetic high-valent metal–oxo catalysts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rana et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: