Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In Part 1, we showed that F(p(e))= x (where x= -ei/T) and F(p1(ei)) + p1(ei)dF/dp1(ei) = a1x both lead to quadratic equations if one uses F(p(ei))= 1/2k ( p power k - p power -k), but that in one case, one has p(ei) unnormalized = { sqrt(1+kkxx) +kx ) power 1/k ((1a)) and in the other p(ei) unnormalized = d power 1/k {sqrt(1+kkx1x1) + kx1) power 1/k ((1b)). In other words, in the second case, there is scaling and an extra weight d which does not affect relative probability. Here we wish to clarify a situation which arises in the Kaniadakis case and the statistical stability method (1). Although the Kaniadakis form: F(p) = 1/k ( p power k - p power -k) does equal -ei/T=x for p(ei) unnormalized for ((1a)), it does not for ((1b)). This is a subtle point because in solving for the Kaniadakis solution from F(p(ei))+p(ei)dF/dp(ei) = ax, one must consider F(p(ei))+ p(ei)dF/dp(ei) combined and so cannot at the same time use the condition that F(p(ei)) = x as it does not for the scaled solution. We give an example. Consider x and -x as RHS values to ((1b)). One might then think that in the Kaniadakis case, one may write two equations, namely ((1b)) with x and another with -x. One may further assume that F(p(ei))=x in the first equation and F(p)= -x in the second, but this is not the case. The solution of ((1b)) does not yield F(p) = x any longer and so it would be incorrect to write p(x)dF/dp(x) + p(-x)dF/dp(-x) = 0. This equation, with 0 replaced with a constant, however, applies to the Maxwell-Boltzmann and Tsallis solutions because the p(ei) in F(p(ei))=x is the same p in the solution fo the differential equation, whereas it is not in the Kaniadakis solution. To describe the situation in another way: F(p(x))= x for the Kaniadakis solution, but for: F(p1(x1)) + p1 dF/dp1 = a*x, F(p1) not= b*x even though F(p) = x Nevertheless, one may solve for p1 = d power 1/k { sqrt(1+kkx1x1)+kx1) power 1/k.. If one sets d=1 and x1 to x, then one obtains p(x) such that F(p(x)) = x.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Francesco Rocco Ruggeri (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: