Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cost behavior theory assumes that costs move proportionately with activity, yet costs may fall by less when sales decline than they rise when sales increase, a pattern known as sticky cost. Evidence on production costs in capital-intensive emerging-market industries remains scarce, as Indonesian studies focus on selling, general, and administrative costs and cost of goods sold. This study examines whether changes in sales are associated with changes in production costs and whether production costs respond asymmetrically to sales increases and decreases. Using annual data of 33 manufacturing firms in the Basic Materials sector listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange over 2020–2024 (132 firm-year changes), we estimate the log-linear model of Anderson, Banker, and Janakiraman (2003). Robustness is assessed with robust, firm-clustered, and wild cluster bootstrap inference, fixed effects, subperiod, and leave-one-out analyses. Production costs respond almost proportionally to sales increases and by less than proportionally to sales decreases, a pattern directionally consistent with sticky cost. However, the asymmetry is statistically fragile: it is significant with conventional standard errors but not with robust, firm-clustered, or bootstrap inference or year fixed effects. It remains significant with firm fixed effects, is concentrated in the earlier years, and is sensitive to individual firms. The study provides cautious evidence on production-cost behavior in a capital-intensive emerging-market sector and shows how inference choices shape sticky-cost conclusions. Managers and analysts should expect production costs to fall more slowly than sales, without assuming stable rigidity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vinka et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: