Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Understanding landscape change in protected mountain areas requires integrating the observation of visible transformations with the social meanings attached to them. The Sierra Nevada Natural Area (Spain), characterised by exceptional biophysical diversity and a long history of human occupation, provides an ideal setting for investigating these interactions. This study evaluates the scientific contribution of the Sierra Nevada Landscape Observatory (OPSiN) after ten years of operation, assessing the potential of repeat photography combined with spatial analysis and public participation to improve the understanding of long-term landscape dynamics. The observatory is based on a network of 145 permanently georeferenced observation points supported by standardised photographic protocols, historical image archives, fieldwork, and participatory processes involving local stakeholders and protected-area managers. Diachronic photographic interpretation enabled the identification of major landscape transformations, including agricultural abandonment, natural vegetation expansion, forest densification, agricultural intensification, tourism-related development and climate-related changes. Comparison between visual evidence and stakeholder perceptions revealed both strong convergences, particularly regarding agricultural abandonment and the deterioration of traditional cultural landscapes, and productive tensions concerning forest expansion, tourism and agricultural intensification, highlighting the complementary nature of scientific observation and local knowledge. The results suggest that repeat photography is particularly useful for documenting gradual socio-ecological transformations that may be difficult to detect with other monitoring approaches. However, photographic evidence alone is insufficient to fully explain landscape dynamics, reinforcing the need to integrate visual monitoring with participatory interpretation and complementary sources of environmental information. The study illustrates how landscape observatories can move beyond documentary functions, and their potential to support adaptive landscape governance, environmental planning and long-term monitoring in protected mountain regions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Caballero‐Calvo et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: