Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article explores how memorable family messages during childhood shape transgender women’s sense of self and emotions in postcolonial Pakistan. The gender order in Pakistan is still governed by the rigid Victorian gender binary norms enacted during British colonial rule. Expressions of femininity in children assigned male at birth are socially condemned and seen as threats to family honor (izzat) and masculinity. Combining insights from the Theory of Memorable Messages (ToMM) and the sociology of emotions, and drawing on 25 in-depth interviews, I demonstrate that transgender children receive hostile messages for gender nonconformity. These messages, I argue, are powerful tools of gender policing that fracture self-concepts and suppress emotions, thus reproducing the colonial logic of control and cisnormativity. Many transgender individuals are forced to leave their biological families and form chosen kinship networks anchored in “dard-e-mushtarik” or “shared pain,” which offer emotional refuge and affirm their self-concepts. Despite living in chosen kinships, they still experience precarious social and emotional existence. This article advances queer and transgender scholarship by illustrating family communication as a site of the colonial legacy of gender regulation. It suggests the importance of emotions in the politics of gender and identity in South Asia. It also calls for greater scholarly, clinical, and policy attention to everyday interactions between transgender children and their parents.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sadia Jamil (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: