Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Operationally successful artificial-intelligence systems can affect the evidence that organizations continue to collect. This creates a scientific problem distinct from predictive accuracy: a system may remain adequate for its operational task while the observation policy surrounding it limits later investigation of alternative relational mechanisms. This conceptual paper develops the Observability Lock-In Hypothesis (OLIH) as a conditional epistemic-feedback account, not as a newly demonstrated empirical effect or physical field. It distinguishes operational continuity, claim-warrant continuity, and historical question-answerability continuity. The proposed Question Survivability Profile (QSP) connects a precisely specified scientific question to rival explanations, evidence requirements, observation-policy provenance, performance dependency, historical recoverability, and bounded qualification outcomes. Applications to industrial Large Signal Field (LSF) candidates and language-agent Large Language Field (LLF) candidates demonstrate how predictive parity can coexist with unequal availability of scientific evidence. Adversarial cases examine recoverable omissions, ethically justified non-retention, conventional methodological equivalence, and structurally indeterminate histories. The framework explicitly inherits foundations from performative prediction, selective labels, missing-data theory, causal identification, provenance, experimental design, and earlier Field Intelligence proposals. No algorithmic superiority, new causal identification theorem, executed benchmark, experiment, verified historical lock-in incident, or independent Field ontology is claimed. The contribution is an incremental, question-indexed conceptual integration for evaluating whether performance-conditioned observation regimes preserve the evidence required for future relational inquiry.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rogério Figurelli (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: