Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Under Scottish law, alcohol availability is regulated through a system of local authority premises licensing. Between 2017–2019, different processes in two cities led to later alcohol trading hours. In Aberdeen City, 38 bars that had previously closed at or before 1am were granted permission for later trading hours. In Glasgow City 10 nightclubs were granted a 1-hour extension to 4am under a pilot scheme. We compare the policy systems and contexts that led to these changes in each city and explore how stakeholder groups engaged with, or influenced, the policy-making process. Methods We analysed 66 policy documents (including consultation responses and meeting minutes, n = 14 from Aberdeen, n = 52 from Glasgow) and conducted semi-structured interviews with 39 local stakeholders (n = 21 from Aberdeen; n = 18 from Glasgow). Documents and interview transcripts were analysed using the Framework approach. Results There was a general lack of transparency in relation to the policy processes in both cities. Trade representatives who favoured liberalisation appeared central to licensing policy decisions, with no evidence of systems in place to take account of conflicts of interest. Decision-making appeared to be based on opinions and visions that were subject to minimal scrutiny and with little or no supporting evidence, and there was no understanding of how evaluation of the impacts of policy changes might aid future decision-making. Conclusion Our findings highlight the need for system reforms to better protect local alcohol licensing policy development from industry interests, introduce transparent policy structures and ensure that relevant, local evidence is understood and valued.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
O’Donnell et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: