Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The difficulty distinguishing between true and false confessions stems, inter alia, from the fact that false confessions often include true details of the crime, divulged to the suspect by police interrogators. This article proposes a novel way of coping with contaminated false confessions, by utilizing the “Guilty Knowledge” polygraph test (GKT), which detects knowledge of concealed information through physiological and behavioral responses. The GKT, I argue, may assist the police and potentially also the criminal courts in ascertaining whether an accused’s knowledge of concealed information is authentic. The article begins by discussing the ethical duty to adopt safety measures against wrongful convictions, namely, constraints and controls designed to prevent the creation of faulty incriminating evidence. I then demonstrate how relying on the GKT would constitute such a safety measure, arguing that its high accuracy, coupled with the lack of reliable alternative measures for evaluating the authenticity of confessions, creates an ethical obligation to use this test. Thus, I suggest that the police conduct GKTs routinely and that it might be time to consider a “confession exception” to the general inadmissibility of polygraph testing in criminal trials, under which the GKT would become admissible only in cases involving contested police confessions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rottem Rosenberg-Rubins (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: