Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Publicly reported kidney transplant outcomes are used for center evaluation, but limited case-mix information and closely clustered outcomes can make comparative rankings appear more precise than the available data justify. This study evaluated multidimensional center performance and the stability of relative rankings using public aggregate data. Data included 423 donor-type records from 227 U.S. kidney transplant centers, representing 148,415 transplants. Expected one-year patient survival and functioning graft proportions were estimated separately for deceased and living donor transplantation using fractional response models with three aggregate measures of recipient composition. Observed-to-expected indices were jointly evaluated using output-oriented data envelopment analysis under variable returns to scale. Stability was assessed by perturbing the reference set and by repeating the full adjustment and benchmarking pipeline within subsamples. Mean quality scores were 0.956 for deceased donor records and 0.979 for living donor records, with one and two strong frontier records, respectively. Unadjusted outcomes produced substantially more frontier records. Among living donor records, 26.9% had adjusted scores of at least 0.990, indicating limited separation near the frontier. Most sensitivity analyses preserved the broader score pattern. Full-pipeline subsampling largely preserved overall ordering but produced greater variation in individual rank percentiles than reference-set perturbation alone. Public aggregate data can support multidimensional comparative assessment of kidney transplant centers, but closely clustered scores and instability in exact rank position limit the interpretation of precise rankings. These measures are better suited to screening and comparative review than to definitive center ranking.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Feyza Gurer (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: