Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Technological trajectories are central to evolutionary economics, yet few empirical instruments observe how variants are generated, selected, and retained or abandoned within populations of research lines. Citation-network studies typically trace trajectories as main paths, a field's dominant line of descent; we extend this program from the route to the population with an unsupervised method. Re-clustering a cumulative citation network annually yields a temporal graph of cluster--year nodes linked by document migration. A deterministic trunk decomposition partitions this graph into lineages: every node belongs to exactly one trajectory. Each trajectory's state names an evolutionary mechanism. Lineages reaching the present take a life-cycle phase from growth and novelty: emergence (variety generation), maturity (retention), or dormancy (exhaustion). Tributaries, which end earlier, take a terminal fate from how their documents disperse: convergence (selection and retention), divergence (variety retained under unresolved selection), or, when extinct, dormancy. Applied to 77,347 biogas documents from OpenAlex, the method finds 19 communities and 98 trajectories. Variety and selection coexist, an open selection environment rather than lock-in: the fastest-growing living lineages are young, and 60 of 79 tributaries fold into surviving lineages, most scattering their documents across several communities. Extinct lineages lose their names but not their papers; among the largest communities, biogas upgrading grew almost entirely on its own, pretreatment largely by absorption. The field moves from rural experimentation (1990s) through industrialization and standardization (2010s) to methods intensification and systems integration (2020s). The open-source R package birddog implements the method. JEL classification: B52, O33, C38, Q55
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Souza et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: