Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Israel and Germany do not just have a special relationship; rather the German Israel policy is modelled upon the highly ambiguous concept of „ Staatsräson “ (reason of state, raison d’état ). The concept has gained increased importance with the Hamas October 2023 assault and the practically unconditional German support of Israel’s military response in Gaza and beyond. This Article will show that the German political discourse ignores the historical roots of the Staatsräson concept Infra Section I. and its tension with a republican Rechtsstaat based on the rule of law, including international law. Infra Section II. In fact, Staatsräson , being a merely political concept, is subordinate to the German Constitution and to international (criminal) law recognized as binding by the Constitution. It may express certain policy preferences, especially in the area of foreign policy, but it can only demand legitimacy as a political concept framed and contained by the Constitution and international law. Against this background it will be shown that the use of the concept with regard to Israel, while firmly rooted in the political discourse, Infra Section II. does not only face theoretical and conceptual challenges but is also instrumentalized to justify government policies which use war as punishment and thus are incompatible with international law. Infra Concluding Remarks. Accordingly, the Article proposes replacing the concept by a more adequate description of the German Israeli relationship based on the principles of international law.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Кай Амбос (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: