Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
First-order kinetics is widely used to compare soil bioremediation treatments but assumes a constant degradation rate. This study developed a hindrance-modified first-order kinetic model (HM-FOKM), applied it to a published pilot-scale dataset, and examined how the fitting method affects the parameters behind remediation forecasts. The HM-FOKM lets the first-order rate constant decline linearly with time and reduces to first-order kinetics when the hindrance coefficient H = 0. Petroleum hydrocarbon and degrader data for natural attenuation, bioaugmentation, biostimulation and combined treatment of crude-oil-contaminated soil (10 weekly samples) were digitised from Yaman (2020). Both models were fitted directly to concentration–time data and compared using R², AICc, an F test and profile-likelihood intervals. The rate–concentration procedure behind the published constants was reconstructed and tested. The HM-FOKM fitted better in all treatments (R² 0.976–0.986 vs 0.905–0.931; ΔAICc 9.8–12.8), with H positive and significant. Published constants, from a rate–concentration regression biased even for first-order data, were 1.5–3.4 times too large. Degradation slowed while degraders were still increasing, indicating substrate-side limitation. Nutrients raised the initial rate 2.7-fold; bioaugmentation alone had little effect. Projected maximum removal was 38–73%, reached at 9.2–10.8 weeks, versus 90% implied by first-order kinetics. Estimating rate constants from linearised or rate-based plots introduces systematic error when degradation slows, and the error propagates into remediation forecasts. Parameters should be fitted directly to concentration–time data. The HM-FOKM, a nested extension of first-order kinetics, separates initial rate from slowdown and better estimates achievable removal.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
yusuf . o. l momoh (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: