Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This protocol sets out how to apply Evidence-Graded Bounds Analysis (EGBA) in a study. EGBA compares two decision options when the quantities that decide the comparison are only partly observed and the available evidence differs in quality. The protocol fixes, before any result is computed, the decision function, the source register and its evidence classes, the rules that turn observations into bounds, the evidence ladder, the paired evaluation, the breakdown frontier and the reporting labels. It also states how amendments, related-party sources, transferred values and exploratory runs are handled. The aim is that any researcher can apply EGBA in the same way and that a reader can check every step. The protocol builds on partial identification (Tamer, 2010), breakdown frontiers (Masten & Poirier, 2020) and evidence grading (Balshem et al., 2011). It is a procedural companion to the EGBA methodological note by the same author This protocol sets out how to apply Evidence-Graded Bounds Analysis (EGBA) in a study. EGBA compares two decision options when the quantities that decide the comparison are only partly observed and the available evidence differs in quality. The protocol fixes, before any result is computed, the decision function, the source register and its evidence classes, the rules that turn observations into bounds, the evidence ladder, the paired evaluation, the breakdown frontier and the reporting labels. It also states how amendments, related-party sources, transferred values and exploratory runs are handled. The aim is that any researcher can apply EGBA in the same way and that a reader can check every step. The protocol builds on partial identification (Tamer, 2010), breakdown frontiers (Masten & Poirier, 2020) and evidence grading (Balshem et al., 2011). It is a procedural companion to the EGBA methodological note by the same author
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Seyed Mehdi Alavi (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: