Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: Mass Media, Consumerism and National Identity in Postwar Japan by Martyn David Smith Julia C. Bullock (bio) Mass Media, Consumerism and National Identity in Postwar Japan. By Martyn David Smith. Bloomsbury Academic, London, 2018. viii, 165 pages. $114.00, cloth; $39.95, paper; $35.95, E-book. Martyn David Smith opens his study of early postwar print media with this enticingly counterintuitive description of the working lives of Japanese circa 1952: Hard work on the part of the Japanese people was essential, but by no means guaranteed. Japanese people were not efficient workers and an eight-hour working day was often equivalent to only two or three hours' work. . . . Creating a prosperous, independent country entailed putting peoples' time and energy to the most effective use. For the Japanese, this required a change in working culture. (p. 1) Given the prevalent stereotype of Japan as a nation of corporate warriors driven by single-minded devotion to economic expansion in the service of "Japan Inc.," this statement serves as a striking reminder of how profoundly our current impression of its national character was forged by the subsequent era of high economic growth. It is this very era that Smith's book seeks to elucidate, centering his analysis (as his title suggests) on the role of popular magazines in shaping Japanese attitudes toward consumerism and what he terms "national subjectivity" between 1952 and 1972. His narrative shines most brightly in these moments when he challenges perceived wisdom by unearthing—or shedding new light on—forgotten chapters of Japan's journey from devastation to prosperity. His study is concerned particularly with the question of how Japan reinvented itself as a nation devoted to peace, prosperity, and consumerism in the wake of defeat in World War II. While this is territory that has been covered by other scholars, his focus on popular magazine articles as primary source materials allows him to connect individual and national histories in sometimes novel ways, by highlighting the extent to which individual readers functioned as both consumers and producers of ideological discourse. Chapter 1 provides a kind of conceptual foundation for the remainder of the study, tracing how print media such as weekly and monthly magazines came to serve as arbiters of "national subjectivity" by increasingly fusing sentiments of national belonging with consumerist culture and cold war values of peace, democracy, and national progress. This chapter is helpful in explaining how Japan was able to maintain the momentum of [End Page 249] economic productivity begun during the Korean War into the following two decades even after the wartime procurements boom came to an end, by shifting focus to domestic production and consumption. Smith effectively connects domestic events such as the rise of "productivity groups" (p. 18) to the broader geopolitical context, demonstrating the degree to which Japan's economic recovery and growth were linked to cold war ideologies and sociohistorical transformations in North America, Europe, and elsewhere. The degree to which individuals were interpellated by these publications as active participants in a community of readership is especially interesting and supports the author's claim that these publications were instrumental in shaping readers' subjectivity as agents of consumerism. Subsequent chapters proceed more or less chronologically, with chapter 2 covering the postoccupation incorporation of "the key terms 'democracy,' 'peace' and 'culture'. . . [into] the discourse over nationalism and the nation" (p. 33). This chapter traces the process whereby "nationalism" was recuperated from the wartime stigma of authoritarianism toward a postwar emphasis on expression of democratic values through consumerism. "Democracy at home and peace abroad would best be achieved by firmly embedding both ideas within the everyday culture of the Japanese people. . . . The need to check the influence of the state to prevent a return to the authoritarianism of wartime would be most effective at the level of everyday life" (p. 33). Chapter 3 addresses the shift to a consumerist model of nationalism from the late 1950s to the Tokyo Olympics of 1964. Here we learn how "the popular media in Japan served to firmly embed the reconstruction of Japanese national identity within the marketing opportunities presented by a vibrant, youth-led consumer society, middle-class domesticity and popular engagement with the...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Julia C. Bullock (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: