Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background: Digital health, sports, and well-being solutions have proliferated rapidly, yet most fail to sustain continued use, even when effective. This gap cannot be explained solely by solution-level factors; it also reflects the economic settings in which they operate. In settings that function as markets, prices, competition, and user choice create incentives that can sustain participation over time. Marketness, the degree to which a setting displays the characteristics of a market, provides a diagnostic framework to assess what the existing evidence does and does not reveal. Without characterizing marketness, investment, regulation, and participation decisions are made without a clear understanding of the market conditions that shape sustained participation. Methods: Following PRISMA guidelines, we systematically searched PubMed, Web of Science, and EconLit for empirical studies of digital health, sports, or well-being solutions. Included studies were assessed against Rosenbaum's four marketness criteria: (1) voluntary and specified exchange, (2) typified goods or services, (3) regularity of exchange, and (4) competition. Studies were grouped into value proposition categories, and each category was then positioned along the marketness continuum, from hierarchy (non-market) to fully constituted market, based on the evidence synthesized across the studies within that category. No category met all four marketness criteria. Condition management approaches the hierarchy end: participation is sustained by clinical endorsement and institutional validation, not market mechanisms. Lifestyle and behavior approaches the market end: exchange terms are commercial, participation is freely initiated, but logging burden, motivational decay, and privacy concerns disrupt regularity. Critically, no included study examined the competition criterion, agent switching, price pressure, or competitive dynamics. Conclusion: The sustained participation gap points to a broader empirical gap: these settings have rarely been examined as markets. The economic mechanisms that could, in principle, sustain participation, competition, pricing, and supply-side responses remain empirically uncharacterized. Future research should examine participation as a comparative choice among alternatives, estimate demand-side parameters from freemium and subscription data, and study developer pricing and competitive responses, providing the empirical foundation currently missing from investment decisions, regulatory frameworks, and participation strategies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hafe et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: