Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Fine needle aspiration cytology is widely advocated as diagnostic tool for pre-operative analysis of thyroid malignancy in patients with scintigraphically cold thyroid nodules (CTN) >10mm size. To assess the contribution of FNAC for differential diagnosis of nodular thyroid disease in daily practice we started a prospective study in 5 thyroid clinics in/around Leipzig, a region with borderline iodine deficiency. 301 FNACs were obtained by 8 different investigators from 244 patients (152 women, 92 men) over a period of 2 years (2002–2004). In addition 37 FNACs were performed intraoperatively. FNACs were reviewed by 3 pathologists with the following diagnoses: 57% benign, 17% follicular neoplasia, 5.2% suspicious, 2.5% malignant, 17.5% non-diagnostic. In addition, an association was noted between the number of thyrocytes/native FNAC smear (+, ++, +++) and the cytological diagnosis of benign (69% +, 29% ++), follicular neoplasia (66% ++, 17% +++), suspicious or malignant FNAC (54%+++, 31% ++) made by the pathologists. A similar correlation was noted for the intraoperatively obtained FNAC for which both cytology and histology were available (14 colloid nodules, 12 follicular adenoma, 3 PTC, 3FTC, 3 autoimmune thyroiditis, 1 Huerthle cell adenoma, 1 lymphoma). When we studied b-actin (house keeping gene) and Tg (thyroid differentiation marker) mRNA expression by real-time PCR, a considerable variation in gene expression/FNAC sample was obtained, challenging the perspective to apply cut-off values for molecular markers in FNA. However there was a trend for lower Tg and higher b-actin expression in FNA samples with follicular or suspicious cytology. In summary, results of FNAC of thyroid nodules in German clinics are in good agreement with results of unselected thyroid nodules reported in the literature. We suggest that besides cytological criteria a high FNA cell yield may not purely represent a “good quality FNA sample“, but may be indicative of a proliferating (follicular) if not transformed thyroid lesion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Karger et al. (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: