Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ineffective phosphorus (P) management in agriculture raises concerns about resource depletion, supply security, eutrophication, and biodiversity loss. A major barrier to more circular and resource-efficient P management is the spatial imbalance between farms: livestock farms often accumulate surplus P from manure in soil, whereas crop farms typically face P deficits that are met with mineral fertilizers. Yet models capable of testing strategies to address these spatial inefficiencies remain limited. We study how a multi‑scale analysis can guide strategies to reduce P imports and soil accumulation in Norway. Using Substance Flow Analysis and farm subsidy statistics, we quantify the P cycles of ~40 000 farms (2019–2023) and aggregate results to municipal, county, and national levels. We then test four manure‑redistribution strategies: on‑farm optimization, and trade at the municipal, county, and national levels. We find that Norwegian agriculture applies 22,1 kt P·yr⁻ 1 to cropland; 4% is lost to runoff and 41% accumulates in soils, particularly in the livestock‑dense Western regions. 9% of harvested crop P is used for direct human consumption, compared to 91% for animal feed. On‑farm optimization reduces mineral P use by 38% and soil accumulation by 36%; municipal and national trade of manure lower P imports by 61% and 78%, and soil accumulation by 65% and 80%, respectively. We provide a reproducible method to build national multi-scale P analyses. Results help identify spatial barriers to circular strategies, indicating where local management is sufficient and where further processing and trade are required.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hernández et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: