Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Increasing shares of variable renewable electricity (VRE) are creating more frequent periods of surplus electricity, increasing the need for flexible options that can absorb and use this excess generation. One option is to convert surplus electricity into heat, but its effective use requires storage when heat production and demand do not coincide. Because heat demand remains concentrated in the colder months, long-duration seasonal thermal storage is needed to bridge this temporal gap. High-temperature aquifer thermal energy storage (HT-ATES) is one technology capable of providing this seasonal storage function. This study develops a demand-oriented operational probability of success (PoS) framework for evaluating whether HT-ATES can convert historically observed surplus electricity into useful seasonal heat. The Neubrandenburg system in Germany was used as a physically grounded reference case. Historical German electricity data from 2015 to 2022 were represented through empirical four-week surplus distributions and coupled to a chronological Monte Carlo inventory model accounting for charging availability, well thermal throughput, adopted storage limit, and thermal recovery. The model first generated a distribution of achievable seasonal heat delivery, which was then evaluated against alternative heat-demand targets. PoS is therefore expressed as the probability that delivered heat meets or exceeds a specified thermal requirement, rather than as a fixed property of the aquifer. For the base configuration, with a thermal power of approximately 3.72 MW, an adopted storage limit of 12 GWh, and a recovery factor of 0.72, the 20,000 retained Monte Carlo cycles produced a mean seasonal delivery of 8.551 GWh. The upper modeled heat delivery of 8.640 GWh was reached in 94.63% of the cycles. Constraint diagnostics showed that well throughput was the unique limiting condition in 57.06% of injection decisions, remaining storage space in 28.82%, and zero-surplus charging windows in 10.90%, while positive-surplus magnitude alone did not limit any base-case injection decision. Sensitivity analyses further showed that increasing thermal power shifts the range of heat-demand targets that can be met with high probability, but the benefit diminishes as the modeled upper delivery limit is approached. Equivalent non-interacting doublet configurations exhibit the same throughput-storage-limit trade-off. The results demonstrate that nominal storage capacity alone is insufficient for assessing HT-ATES performance. Operational success depends jointly on charging opportunities, thermal power, storage capacity, thermal recovery, system configuration, and the thermal target used to define success. The proposed framework provides a transferable screening method for linking historical energy-system variability with subsurface storage constraints and explicit heat-delivery requirements.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sangin et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: