Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Oath-taking ceremonies in constitutional monarchies bring legally regulated appointment procedures into contact with inherited material symbols. This qualitative case study examines the Lembing Sembuana as a non-verbal medium during the oath-taking of ten Selangor State Executive Council (EXCO) members at Istana Alam Shah on 21 August 2023. Data comprise three separate formal interviews with palace-related informants (approximately 45 minutes each, conducted in person with signed consent, video recording, written notes and verbatim transcription), comparative direct observation of a 2018 dignitary ceremony, and visual records of the 2023 EXCO event. Combining James W. Carey's ritual view of communication with Roland Barthes' denotation, connotation and myth, the study differentiates observable actions, meanings attributed by customary sources and the researcher's ideological interpretation. The researcher confirms an identical protocol among all ten EXCO members: standing at a prescribed position, receiving the spear before the oath, holding it upright in the right hand while reading from a written text held in the left, and returning it after recitation. At the denotative level, this is a coordinated sequence of bodily and material signs; connotatively, palace accounts associate the spear with daulat, allegiance, moral accountability and tulah. At the mythic level, ritual repetition can naturalise the coexistence of elected administration and inherited royal custom without showing that the artefact confers legal office. Comparison with the fuller Istiadat Menjunjung Duli practice highlights the distinct protocols of administrative officeholders and titled dignitaries. Although public protocol was uniform across a diverse group, the study does not infer identical private beliefs or measured spatial distances. The findings locate the spear's role in institutional communication rather than independent constitutional authority.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jalil et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: