Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Classical analytic epistemology routinely treats doxastic states as cost-free propositional variables suspended in an abstract logical vacuum. Grounding epistemology in Karl Friston’s Free Energy Principle, Rolf Landauer’s information physics, and functional neuroimaging reveals that human cognition operates within an energy-constrained biological organ. Under active inference, belief functions as the overarching generative genus of conscious thought, while knowledge claims, active and passive disbelief, and suspension of judgment operate as nested, metabolically distinct clades. Drawing on a formalized Thermodynamic State-Space Model (TSSM), this paper demonstrates how sustained executive opposition or stalemate eventually crosses a critical metabolic threshold (C_crit), triggering a nonlinear "dogmatic phase collapse" into low-friction automated priors. This framework exposes how contemporary "agnostic atheism" and online Street Epistemology conflate human fallibilism with functional disbelief, commit black-and-white and black swan fallacies through a misapplication of statistical null hypothesis testing, and systematically erase Thomas Henry Huxley’s standalone agnostic position. Finally, we show how asymmetric-stakes decision paradigms distinguish genuine, high-cost Huxleyan neutrality from low-effort "assertoric retreats."
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Benjamin Ruby (2026) studied this question.