Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper evaluates at what envelope temperature and, under a standard temperature profile, at what radius each principal ice species sublimates, and how the residence time on the grain collapses across that boundary in NGC 1333 IRAS4, using published physical conditions as fixed inputs rather than fitted parameters. The adopted molecular hydrogen density is 1e+06 per cubic centimetre at 10 K. From those inputs the freeze-out time for water is 4.65e+03 yr, compared with a free-fall time of 3.08e+07 yr, giving a ratio of 0.0002. The critical density of the reference transition is 3.5e+07 per cubic centimetre, so the core density exceeds it by a factor of 0.0286. The depletion factor implied by the canonical and observed abundances is 1e+03, leaving a gas fraction of 0.001. Thermal desorption balances accretion only near 107 K, well above the adopted temperature, while the cosmic-ray desorption time is 1.37e+06 yr and the representative gas-phase reaction time is 0.6 yr. Together these numbers place the chemistry of NGC 1333 IRAS4 in a definite regime: accretion and ion-molecule processing are fast enough to shape the observed composition, thermal return is negligible, and any sustained gas-phase presence of strongly bound species must be maintained by non-thermal return or by incomplete exposure time. All values are computed from the stated inputs with the deposited code.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.