Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose To evaluate arthroscopic stabilization versus nonoperative management for first‐time traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation in adult athletes, with a focus on recurrent instability, return‐to‐play rates, and time to return to play. Methods Five databases were searched from inception to July 2025. Studies comparing arthroscopic stabilization versus nonoperative management in adult athletes (≥18 years) with first‐time traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation were included. The primary outcome was recurrent instability. Secondary outcomes included return‐to‐play rates and time to return to play. A narrative synthesis was performed given the nonrandomized and heterogeneous nature of included studies. Evidence certainty was assessed using Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation. Results Five studies (232 participants: 111 operative, 121 nonoperative) were included. Recurrent instability rates ranged from 3% to 14% in the operative group and 24% to 80% in the nonoperative group. Return‐to‐play rates were high for both approaches (operative: 93%‐100%; nonoperative: 97%‐100%). Nonoperative management was associated with earlier return to sport (2.3‐5.7 weeks vs 18.7‐39.3 weeks for operative management in studies reporting this outcome). All studies involved elite athletes, with female athletes substantially under‐represented. Conclusions Arthroscopic stabilization was consistently associated with lower rates of recurrent instability than nonoperative management after first‐time traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation but required a longer time to return to play. Nonoperative management enabled an earlier return to play but was associated with higher recurrence. The evidence is limited primarily to male military, collegiate, and professional athletes, restricting generalizability to female, recreational, and broader adult athletic populations. Level of Evidence Level III, systematic review of Level II and III studies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fraser et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: