Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose The purpose of this study is to examine whether firms’ environmental, social, and governance (ESG) initiatives entail trade-offs with tax planning activities or can be strategically aligned to enhance corporate performance. This study investigates the extent to which deviation of a firm’s observed tax effectiveness from the level its ESG profile predicts is associated with firm performance. Design/methodology/approach Using a panel of United States (US) publicly traded firms from 2014 to 2023, the authors develop ESG–tax strategic alignment (ETSA), a residual-based measure of deviation from ESG-implied tax expectations, and examine its association with operational and market performance. Findings This study finds a negative average relationship between ESG performance and tax effectiveness, consistent with a structural trade-off in which sustainability commitment constrains the scope of tax planning. Against this baseline, ETSA is positively associated with both operational and market performance across contemporaneous, lagged, matched-sample and system-GMM specifications. An exploratory decomposition shows that falling short of ESG-implied tax expectations carries a larger operational cost than exceeding them carries a benefit; the pattern reverses for market valuation. The market-valuation association weakens marginally after the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, while the operational association is stable. Research limitations/implications The study relies on observational panel data, and the documented relationships represent associations rather than definitive causal effects. Future research could exploit exogenous shocks such as tax governance reforms or mandatory disclosure mandates to strengthen causal identification. The sample covers only US-listed firms, whose institutional environment limits the generalisability of the results. ETSA itself rests on the modelling assumptions of its first-stage regression and inherits the measurement limitations of ESG ratings that may capture disclosure quality rather than substantive ESG performance. Originality/value The authors extend the ESG–tax literature by measuring deviation from an empirically documented ESG–tax trade-off, rather than treating ESG and tax conduct as independent constructs, and by showing that this deviation is systematically associated with firm performance. The authors interpret the channel-differentiated pattern through legitimacy and signalling frameworks, as theoretically motivated reading rather than directly tested mechanisms.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wibowo et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: