Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article examines how narrative power shapes recognition and legitimacy in state‐led consultation procedures with Indigenous communities. Analysing two non‐binding consultations involving the Bedouin community in Israel, the study applies a voice‐centric computational methodology to over 200 oral testimonies. Using topic modelling and statistical analysis, it reveals a persistent narrative divide: Bedouin speakers foregrounded historical narratives of communal land possession with odds more than eight times higher than those of non‐Bedouin participants, while state actors relied predominantly on legalistic and procedural discourse oriented towards future governance. This divergence reflects competing conceptions of justice. For Indigenous participants, the past constituted the foundation of their claims, and the recognition of historical connection and dispossession was a prerequisite for negotiating future arrangements. The state, by contrast, largely bracketed history in favour of formal legal entitlements and procedural frameworks that operate to the detriment of Bedouin claims. An analysis of the Goldberg Commission's final report shows that this legalistic framing was ultimately adopted as the Commission's dominant narrative. By shifting analytical attention from speaking to listening, the article advances socio‐legal scholarship and offers methodological and policy insights for designing consultation processes that more meaningfully engage with and listen to Indigenous voices.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Levine‐Schnur et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: