Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper computes an orbital-evolution budget for the young Sun, taken as one solar mass, focusing on a proposed inward excursion of Jupiter to about 1.5 astronomical units followed by an outward return locked with Saturn. Using the published periods, masses and radii listed in the Methods, Keplerian energies and angular momenta are derived for each planet, Type I disc torques and migration timescales are evaluated at a stated surface density, period ratios are compared with their nearest commensurabilities, and tidal circularisation times are estimated from a standard scaling. The innermost planet orbits at 5.2012 astronomical units with a migration timescale of 2.48e+03 years under the stated disc, while the outermost considered here orbits at 9.5379 astronomical units with a migration timescale of 1.12e+04 years. The largest departure from an exact adjacent commensurability is 0.669 per cent. The central question is how much orbital energy and angular momentum that excursion exchanges with the disc, and whether the torque reversal condition is comfortably or marginally met. The budget shows which parts of that history ordinary disc and tidal physics can supply, which parts require slower migration, stronger damping or a different disc, and which numbers would change the conclusion if revised observations moved them. All values are computed from the stated inputs; none is a new measurement.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: