Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Two frameworks have contested substorm onset for three decades: reconnection at a near-Earth neutral line around twenty to twenty-five Earth radii, which then drives flows earthward, and current disruption in the near-Earth plasma sheet around seven to nine Earth radii, which launches a rarefaction and signal tailward. This paper places both on one event geometry and one energy requirement and computes what each must deliver. Reconnection at 22 Earth radii with the stated inflow conditions processes power at 2.26e+11 W over a thirty Earth radii X-line with a twenty Earth radii inflow extent, needing about 74 minutes to supply a 1e15 J substorm. The magnetic energy available from a 20 nT field change inside the adopted disruption volume at 8 Earth radii is 2.06e+12 J, about one percent of the requirement, so current disruption cannot be the energy source and must be a trigger or a coupling step drawing on lobe storage through the field. The Alfvenic communication time between the two sites is 172 seconds, inside the timing uncertainty of most event studies, which is why single-event timing has not settled the contest and why the energy roles, source against trigger, are the cleaner discriminator.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: