Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
It seems that many people believe that Bach’s greatness as a composer lies in some kind of mathematical mastery of music; the math of music is widely exaggerated, in any case (it’s largely fairly basic arithmetic, for one thing). To be sure, Bach himself promoted his own image as a “learned musician” (the subtitle of Cristoph Wolff’s biography) and was undoubtedly proud of his ability immediately to grasp the fugal possibilities of a theme (as in the well-known anecdote relayed by Carl Philipp Emanuel). That can hardly account for the emotional impact Bach’s music has on listeners, however—contrary to a certain kind of theorist who seems to believe it can and despite those who find his music “cold” or “dry” (maybe at times mostly as a result of someone’s overselling the learnedness). This essay analyzes the two twelve-bar phrases that make up three quarters of the material of the final chorus of the Matthew Passion, particularly, the second phrase. It shows how they are “predicted” early in the work (much as Jesus predicts the ultimate events of his life) and, in effect, depict some of the most visceral aspects of the crucifixion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Arthur Maisel (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: