Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Preclinical evaluation of new orthopaedic implants is typically undertaken using cadaveric bone as it provides the most authentic match to the mechanical properties of human bone in vivo . However, the properties of cadaveric bone are highly dependent on physiological factors leading to uncertainty in test results. As an alternative, investigations have been undertaken into the potential suitability of bone surrogates that are capable of replicating bone performance and overcoming some of the complications associated with cadaveric bone, especially in early-stage research. However, these models have been criticised for their performance, which is further impeded by the lack of standardisation in characterising these structures for utilisation in scenario-specific applications. This systematic review, following the protocol outlined by the PRISMA-2020 methodology, synthesises findings from 88 papers on the mechanical characterisation methods and associated properties of bone surrogates, with results demonstrating significant variations in study design, thus restricting the potential for comparison. Due to the hierarchical structure of bone, its mechanical properties are highly influenced by anatomical factors, meaning researchers must ensure surrogate properties align with data from cadaveric bone of the same physiological condition and characterised using an equivalent testing mechanism. Of the studies included in this review, just 23 of 88 characterised the properties of human cadaveric bone alongside the surrogates, with the majority comparing to data from literature obtained using inconsistent loading protocols. Adoption of standards and protocols for production and characterisation of bone surrogates would allow for greater understanding of research gaps that must be addressed prior to replacement of cadaveric bone in orthopaedic research. By consolidating current research, this review aims contribute towards the development of future surrogates capable of representing the complex anatomical and mechanical properties of bone during scenario-specific applications.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gargan et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: