Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Changes in planted forests (PF) and natural forests (NF) can affect regional temperature and relative humidity (RH), but their relative responses under contrasting water conditions remain unclear. We incorporated prescribed PF and NF spatial distributions and their associated satellite-derived vegetation and radiative properties into Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) sensitivity experiments to examine scenario-based hydrothermal responses across China. Spatial and seasonal comparisons were combined with forest-area–leaf-area-index (LAI)-normalized sensitivities, surface-energy decomposition, continuous moisture-gradient analysis, and humidity-pathway diagnostics. The simulated responses were strongly conditioned by regional water availability. In humid Southern China, the PF scenario produced spring cooling of − 0.316 K and an RH increase of + 0.999%, with April responses reaching − 0.730 K and + 2.349%, respectively. A similarly strong early-season response occurred in the Yunnan–Guizhou Plateau, whereas PF cooling in the relatively water-limited Loess Plateau was delayed until May–June. After differences in forest-area and LAI changes were jointly considered, the PF scenario retained comparatively high temperature and humidity sensitivities in Southern China and the Yunnan–Guizhou Plateau. This result indicates that their stronger PF responses were not attributable solely to the larger magnitude of the prescribed vegetation perturbations. The surface-energy decomposition provided a physical explanation for this regional contrast. Cooling in Southern China and the Yunnan–Guizhou Plateau was dominated by latent-heat contributions of − 0.217 and − 0.276 K, respectively, indicating that sufficient water availability supported evapotranspiration-related cooling. In the relatively water-limited Loess Plateau, by contrast, the latent-heat contribution of − 0.108 K was substantially offset by + 0.187 K of sensible heating. The PF−NF contrast changed in both magnitude and direction across the evaporative-fraction gradient, indicating a nonlinear dependence on background water conditions. Continuous soil–water interaction analyses showed a consistent tendency toward relatively stronger PF-associated cooling and moistening with increasing water availability, although the interaction magnitude remained uncertain. Together, these results show that sufficient water availability supports stronger and earlier PF-associated evapotranspiration, latent-heat cooling, and near-surface moistening, whereas water limitation strengthens sensible-heat compensation and makes the PF−NF contrast weaker, delayed, or less consistently differentiated. Because the experiments prescribe forest distributions and satellite-derived surface properties rather than complete forest-type-specific physiological traits, the findings represent moisture-conditioned scenario responses rather than universal intrinsic differences between PF and NF.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: