Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We prove that the fourth secant varieties of the Grassmannian Gr(3,9) ⊂ P(Λ³C⁹) and of the spinor variety S16 ⊂ P^127 are not normal along their third secant varieties. In both cases the third secant variety is not projectively normal. These results follow from a local obstruction for orbit closures in θ-representations whose general points are conjugate into a linear subspace of a Cartan subspace. The normalization of the invariant quotient is a finite-group quotient. Under explicit slice hypotheses, a mismatch between two sets of degrees forces the normalization map to fail on cotangent spaces: the degrees of the local reflection group, and the invariant degrees of an ambient parabolic subgroup. This detects non-normality of the projective variety itself and locates it along an orbit-closure stratum. The two varieties live in the two θ-representations of e8 (the Z/3- and Z/2-gradings). Ternary cubics and four qubits provide the orbit-closure models for their fourth secant varieties, and in both cases the obstruction occurs in degree three. We also determine the invariant ring of the cone over the fourth secant variety of Gr(3,9), and identify the non-normal locus of the invariant quotient in both cases. As a contrasting application, we prove that Strassen's hypersurface σ4(P²×P²×P²) is normal; together with known results, this implies that every secant variety of P²×P²×P² is projectively normal. Its relative and local groups coincide with those of Gr(3,9), so normality is governed by the ambient group and not by the orbit-closure model alone. Finally, we describe the local groups at strata of flats and classify the degree-gap obstruction for the Weyl groups containing −1 and for W(E6). All computations are carried out in exact arithmetic (integer, rational or cyclotomic). Floating point is used only to search for candidates, which are then verified exactly.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
JOSÉ TORREGROSA JIMÉNEZ (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: