Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A pure qubit state is a point of CP¹ ≅ S², determined by an oriented Bloch vector n. Wildberger’s universal hyperbolic geometry (UHG), in its elliptic form, works instead on the real projective plane RP², where n and −n are identified. This is an additional quotient and not the quantum projectivization, because n and −n are orthogonal states. This note asks which parts of the three-state Bargmann invariant are determined by a UHG triangle of Bloch axes, and which require oriented or spinorial data. Main results Quaternionic realization of the Bargmann invariant. Using Wildberger’s projective quaternion description of SO(3), the ordered product K = E₁₂E₂₃E₃₁ of the canonical positive-scalar quaternion representatives of the three shortest edge rotations satisfies K = 8 Φn₁(Δ₃), where Δ₃ is the Bargmann invariant and Φn₁ embeds the complex numbers in the quaternion plane spanned by 1 and n₁. The oriented base axis n₁ supplies the complex structure. The rotation of K gives only the doubled angle. Quadrea identity. The elliptic UHG quadrea equals one minus the half spread of the rotation represented by the product of the three half-turns, and equals 16 (Im Δ₃)². Eight sign choices. The sign changes nᵢ → ±nᵢ give the same UHG triangle but up to eight distinct physical triples. The paper tabulates which quantities are invariant: quadrances, quadrea and the half-turn rotation are, while the Bargmann value and K take at most eight and four values respectively. A global flip leaves K unchanged and conjugates Δ₃. Rational arithmetic. For rational Bloch vectors, the holonomy rotation has a norm-one rational quaternion representative if and only if |Δ₃|² is a rational square. A worked example shows a rational rotation with no rational unit quaternion representative. The motivation is Freed’s thesis that quantum theory is projective while quantization is linear. The paper uses it to separate three notions: the scalar quotient, the positive-ray double cover, and the spinor-norm obstruction. No claim is made about anomalies, gerbes, or field theory.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John D. Coady (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: