Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper computes a tidal budget from published inputs and standard relations, with every number produced by the deposited script. The headline results are: flux e01 = 4.607; flux e02 = 18.43; flux e035 = 56.44; e for Io flux = 0.07; e for Earth flux = 0.014. The answer is controlled almost entirely by one poorly known number, the eccentricity, which radial-velocity data leave anywhere between zero and a few tenths. At the reference response, an eccentricity of a tenth already yields a flux of several watts per square metre, tens of times Earth's internal heat flow; two tenths reach tens of watts per square metre, the regime of strong geological processing; and the eccentricity at which the flux would reach Io's value can be computed exactly and lies within the allowed range. A circular, synchronous Proxima b, by contrast, has essentially no eccentricity heating at all. Tidal heating for this planet is therefore not a value but a fork, and the paper maps both branches of it.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.