Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Context Smallholder farming systems in Africa face complex soil- and climate-related constraints. The lack of knowledge about persistent soil constraints limits the scalability of management practices because their impacts on soil health indicators and crop productivity are rarely analysed in an integrated manner taking into account prevailing farming systems and soil constraints. Objectives This work combined a systematic review and meta-analysis to (i) explicitly link soil constraints with the performance of soil health-promoting practices and (ii) identify context-specific opportunities for scaling these practices across smallholder farming systems in Africa. Methods A systematic review was used to synthesize evidence on dominant soil constraints and their interaction with management practices across farming systems. Building on this, a meta-analysis quantified the effects of key agronomic practices on soil health indicators and crop yields across diverse farming systems, soil types, crop types, and soil degradation gradients, enabling a constraint-specific evaluation of agronomic practices. Results and Conclusion Integrated soil fertility management (ISFM) and sole application of organic inputs (biochar, compost, manure, green manure, crop residues) significantly increased soil organic carbon, nutrient availability, cation exchange capacity and pH, while reducing soil bulk density. These practices also delivered the most consistent yield gains, outperforming fertilizer-only interventions. The analysis also provided three novel insights. First, the magnitude of gains from agronomic practice are conditioned by underlying soil constraints, demonstrating that variability in outcomes is not random but structurally driven. Second, integrated use of agronomic practices results in superior performance by addressing multiple constraints, rather than a single limiting factor. Third, the study introduced a constraints-informed scaling perspective, arguing for alignment of interventions with specific soil functional limitations to increase their effectiveness and scalability. Significance By explicitly linking soil constraints with agronomic intervention performance, this study advances a shift from practice-based to constraint-informed scaling strategies. It provides a novel, systems-oriented evidence for designing targeted, high-impact and scalable soil health interventions that enhance productivity and resilience of smallholder farming systems in Africa.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rasche et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: