Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background: Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly integrated into clinical practice and medical education, yet research on AI and medical professional identity has largely evolved in parallel. Objective: To examine how AI is transforming fundamental components of medical professional identity and propose a framework for understanding its implications for professional identity formation in medical education. Methods: This narrative review synthesizes conceptual, empirical, and theoretical literature on AI, professional identity formation, and clinical practice through iterative literature searching and citation tracking. Peer-reviewed studies, regulatory data, and national survey reports were considered. Results: AI affects professional identity unevenly. Diagnostic, predictive, generative, and emerging autonomous systems most directly influence expertise, clinical reasoning, and professional autonomy, shifting physicians from exclusive holders of specialized knowledge toward validators of increasingly accessible but variably trusted information. Evidence of automation bias and reduced diagnostic performance highlights this transition. We conceptualize the divergence between the formal locus of clinical responsibility, which remains with physicians, and the functional locus of influence decisions, shared with AI, as the formal–functional gap (FFG). Its magnitude varies by AI configuration, identity component, and career stage, potentially placing trainees at risk of never-skilling and experienced physicians at risk of deskilling. Ethical responsibility, humanistic care, lifelong learning, and professional authority are affected more indirectly. Conclusion: AI-mediated professional identity change reflects a dynamic interaction between physicians’ developmental trajectories and evolving AI capabilities. Medical education should prioritize sustained expertise, clinical reasoning, professional autonomy, AI-interpretive judgment, and human oversight. The FFG remains a conceptual framework whose relationships require empirical validation. Plain Language Summary: Artificial intelligence (AI) tools are now common in hospitals and medical schools. They help with diagnosing diseases, writing notes, and answering medical questions. While these tools can improve care, they also raise important questions about what it means to be a doctor. This review looked at how AI is changing the professional identity of physicians — the sense of who they are and what they are responsible for. We examined existing research, expert opinions, and real-world examples of AI use in medicine. We found that AI does not affect all parts of a doctor’s role equally. It has the strongest impact on medical knowledge, clinical decision-making, and professional independence. Doctors are shifting from being the only source of specialized knowledge to checking and interpreting information that AI systems provide. At the same time, legal responsibility for patient care still rests with the physician. We call this mismatch between formal responsibility and actual influence the “formal–functional gap”. This gap can create different risks. Medical students may never fully develop key skills if they rely too heavily on AI from the start. Experienced doctors may lose some of their skills over time through reduced practice. Other important parts of being a doctor — such as ethical responsibility, empathy, and lifelong learning — are affected more indirectly. These findings matter for medical education. Training programmes should protect doctors’ ability to think independently, teach them how to critically evaluate AI suggestions, and ensure that human oversight remains meaningful. The goal is not to reject AI, but to make sure that technology strengthens rather than weakens the core values and skills of the medical profession.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hejazi et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: