Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This review systematizes the least understood aspects of the structure of inorganic compounds at three levels: partial models, real structure, and orders that extend beyond atomic coordinates. It is shown that structural inorganic chemistry does not operate with a single unifying theory but with a mosaic of partial models – the ionic model with Pauling's rules, the valence-shell electron-pair repulsion (VSEPR) model, the Wade-Mingos rules, the Zintl-Klemm concept, and band theory – each of which has a poorly delineated domain of applicability. A direct statistical test of classical crystal-chemical rules against large experimental datasets has revealed unexpectedly low predictive power, including for Pauling's rules and the Goldschmidt tolerance factor. The review further addresses crystal structure prediction as an NP-hard optimization problem; the least-studied structural states and phenomena, including the amorphous state, correlated disorder, nonstoichiometry (Berthollide phases), mixed valence, the stereochemical activity of lone pairs, quasicrystals, high-pressure chemistry, 5f-electron systems, and the superionic state; the genesis of structure through classical and non-classical nucleation theory; the real, defective architecture of grain boundaries and complexions, dislocations in ionic crystals, polar surfaces, and the solid-water interface; the discrepancy between average crystallographic structure and local dynamic structure in BaTiO3, relaxor ferroelectrics, and halide perovskites; configurationally complex and high-entropy phases; and the methodological reliability of structural databases, including documented cases of misassigned space groups and fabricated structures. A separate section systematizes orders that are not reducible to atomic positions: charge, spin, and orbital ordering (the Mott-Peierls problem in VO2, charge density waves, the cuprate pseudogap), magnetic crystallography and the recently established class of altermagnets (including the ongoing revision of its reference material), the topological dimension of structure and the role of spin-orbit coupling, hydrogen as a systematic blind spot of X-ray diffraction rather than of diffraction as such (including the reproducibility crisis surrounding claims of room-temperature superconductivity), chemical bonds that resist classification (electrides, quintuple bonds, metallophilic and sigma-hole interactions), and non-equilibrium hidden phases. Two constructive counterexamples are discussed at length: the modern (Berry-phase) theory of polarization and quantum crystallography, both of which show that the atomic-coordinate model can be correctly extended rather than merely declared incomplete. It is argued that quantum mechanics constitutes a unified theory of structure only in Dirac's foundational sense, while, operationally, structural chemistry remains irreducibly pluralistic and multi-object, in the sense articulated by Anderson's emergentism. A productive research program is therefore identified not as the pursuit of a single all-encompassing theory, but as the systematic mapping of the domains of applicability of existing models, the construction of transition rules between them, and the well-defined extension of the structural model itself. The practical stakes of this program are illustrated through composite ion-exchangers and carbon-nanomaterial-functionalized membranes, in which the poorly characterized structure of the disordered hydrous-oxide layer directly governs sorption selectivity and ion transport.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yevhen Kolomiiets (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: