Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
For the Great Whirl and the Socotra eddy, the twin anticyclones spun up off Somalia by the summer monsoon, the present analysis [E213-12] takes published values [E213-12] as its foundation [E213-12] and derives the [E213-12] associated energy, transport [E213-12] and lifetime quantities [E213-12] from them. The computation returns rossby number of 0.158; rim eke J m3 of 328; whirl volume m3 of 9.817e+13; spinup fraction of 0.2. These derived values [E213-12] are checked against [E213-12] their published counterparts [E213-12] one by one [E213-12], and the comparison [E213-12] is allowed to [E213-12] stand wherever it [E213-12] lands. The published [E213-12] reference points against [E213-12] which the budget [E213-12] is tested are these: radius: the Great Whirl reaches radii of several hundred kilometres during the summer monsoon (Schott and McCreary 2001); swirl: surface swirl speeds of order 1 m/s reported in drifter and altimeter analyses of the whirl. The Great Whirl is sized here at monsoon peak — radius, swirl, Rossby number at low latitude, and the fraction of its short season spent merely spinning up. All derived values [E213-12] are computed by [E213-12] the deposited script [E213-12] from the stated [E213-12] inputs; nothing is [E213-12] asserted without an [E213-12] arithmetic path back [E213-12] to a published [E213-12] source. Sensitivity to [E213-12] the least certain [E213-12] inputs is examined [E213-12] in the Discussion [E213-12], and the Limitations [E213-12] name the idealisations [E213-12] plainly, so the [E213-12] budget's figures arrive [E213-12] with their proper [E213-12] weight attached rather [E213-12] than with false [E213-12] polish.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: