Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Every frazil crystal in a river begins as a speck a few micrometres across, in water only hundredths of a degree too cold, and within the hour it can be a disc a millimetre wide on its way to becoming a floc, a pan, a jam. This paper computes that first growth, using the thermal growth law for disc crystals in supercooled water with the laboratory magnitudes reported in the frazil literature. Growth is fastest when the crystal is smallest: at a supercooling of five hundredths of a degree, a crystal of radius one hundred micrometres grows at about 0.9 micrometres per second, while the same law at a millimetre gives a tenth of that pace, because the latent heat of each new layer must be conducted away through the crystal's own neighbourhood. Integrating the law, a nucleus needs 90 minutes to reach a millimetre radius at five hundredths of a degree of supercooling, 224 minutes at two hundredths, and only 45 minutes at a tenth — the full span of supercoolings rivers actually sustain, mapping onto the observed fact that frazil appears in quantity within tens of minutes of a reach going supercooled. A population of 1e+07 crystals per cubic metre grown to half-millimetre discs makes a suspension of 0.04 percent by volume, the dilute end of measured frazil concentrations; reaching the rich concentrations of an active run requires the multiplication that secondary nucleation — crystals breeding crystals in collisions — supplies, and the budget shows the growth law alone, without that multiplication, cannot people a river fast enough.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: