Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Version 1.0 (Preliminary Empirical Study) Baseline cross-system evaluation prior to the full 10-mask, 240-trial benchmark Presentation Attack Detection (PAD) in facial recognition largely relies on the assumption that effective three-dimensional (3D) facial spoofing requires expensive, custom-molded silicone or resin prosthetics. In this preliminary empirical study, we investigate whether ultra-low-cost, off-the-shelf printed fabric masks featuring celebrity faces can erode biometric verification margins and approach false positive decision thresholds across diverse deep learning architectures. Unlike flat prints or digital screen replays, wearable stretchable textiles conform naturally to the attacker's 3D facial geometry and head movements without specialized fabrication. We evaluate two consecutive physical captures of a commercial printed fabric celebrity mask against a reference enrollment image across eight widely used open-source facial recognition models (ArcFace, FaceNet, FaceNet-512, VGG-Face, SFace, GhostFaceNet, OpenFace, and DeepID). Experimental measurements show that while strict default thresholds prevented outright false positives in single-reference baseline trials, improving capture alignment reduced cosine distances to within critical proximity of acceptance thresholds—reaching 0.6564 against a 0.6500 threshold on GhostFaceNet (a margin of 0.0064) and 0.0267 against 0.0150 on DeepID. These initial findings challenge the traditional cost-barrier assumption and establish the empirical foundation for our ongoing 10-mask, 240-trial cross-system benchmark.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Velasco Gómez Miguel (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: