Key result
Spiritual and religious practices are linked to improved cardiovascular outcomes, including lower mortality risk.
Why the study?
Spirituality and religious beliefs shape perception of health, lifestyle, compliance, and self-care in patients with chronic CVD, yet these attributes are often de-emphasized in clinical medicine in favour of hard science results.
Does engaging in spiritual and meditative practices improve cardiovascular outcomes and physiological risk factors in patients with cardiovascular disease?
Does engaging in spiritual and meditative practices improve cardiovascular outcomes and physiological risk factors in patients with cardiovascular disease?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This narrative review highlights the potential neuro-psycho-physiological mechanisms and clinical benefits of spiritual and meditative practices on cardiovascular outcomes, advocating for the integration of spiritual history-taking into routine cardiovascular care.
Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is the leading cause of morbidity and mortality in industrialized nations as well as in many developing countries. Most disorders of the cardiovascular system, except for some relatively rare arrhythmias tend to be chronic, with the probability of recurrence and progression over one’s lifetime. Illness can refocus attention on the meaning of life, purpose, and relationship to self, family, community, and whatever is held sacred. It can force the mending of relationships, gaining fresh perspectives, and re-prioritizing life to align with what one holds to be most important. This shift of perspective can have unquantifiable effects on compliance, self-care, and indirectly on clinical outcomes. Although the ‘soft’ attributes of life tend to be self-evident, their de-emphasis in favour of ‘hard’ science results is an unfortunate oversight in clinical medicine. Even when physicians themselves subscribe to faith, hope, and an overarching philosophy that guides their own lives, these aspects are often glossed over as being unimportant in the science of medicine. Spirituality is loosely defined as a personalized, naturally occurring phenomenon where one seeks a connectedness with a higher purpose or force, which lies outside of ordinary existence, and is inherently associated with an overarching meaning of life. While it is tempting to differentiate spirituality and religiosity based on specific practices or organized structures, respectively, there tends to be a significant overlap between the two. Spiritual experiences (like oneness or unconditional love) can and do occur within the religious context. Conversely, although practices such as mindfulness and yoga are secular, they can lead to ‘spiritual’ experiences, and although not specifically associated with religion, were developed within the broader context of Buddhism and Hinduism, respectively. Importantly, spirituality and religious beliefs tend to shape cultural and moral beliefs, perception of health and disease, lifestyle, and daily habits (Figure 1). In this review, we refer to spirituality as the combination of philosophy and practices that may or may not fall into specifically religious categories. Spirituality and faith often provide an overarching philosophy that permeate all facets of life, including cultural and moral norms, which impact perception of health and disease, lifestyle, and habits, as well as healthcare choices (such as injunctions to avoid certain treatments that oppose spiritual/religious beliefs). Spirituality and faith often provide an overarching philosophy that permeate all facets of life, including cultural and moral norms, which impact perception of health and disease, lifestyle, and habits, as well as healthcare choices (such as injunctions to avoid certain treatments that oppose spiritual/religious beliefs). A potential significant limitation in this field is the subjective vs. objective measurement of what is defined as spiritual. Objective measures assume that a given experience fits into the parameters of language that assess the emotional, behavioural, and cognitive measures that are used to describe it. Since these experiences occur subjectively in wordless states, what one person calls ‘God’ or ‘divine’ may not apply to someone else having the same experience. Notably, there is no standardized measure to determine if two experiences are indeed the same. While there has been growing interest in this area with some research, the lack of technology to objectively measure spiritual experiences may lead to the denial of the existence and importance of such experiences, which are all too real for those having them. Objective measures of spirituality span a variety of physiological measures. Given the close proximity of data from meditative practices to spontaneous experiences that may be deemed spiritual, they form the basis for an understanding of the neuro-psycho-physiological effects on CVD. Here, we consider their effects on the autonomic nervous system (ANS), hormonal and immunological, and the central nervous system. Changes in the ANS related to spiritual practices are far from being straightforward and are shown to involve both arousal and relaxation (Figure 2).1 The technique being employed in spiritual practice appears to determine the various, and seemingly opposing ANS effects. The most available data are for centred mindfulness and transcendental meditation (TM). Mindfulness is a technique that stresses a moment-to-moment non-judgmental focus on the content of one's mental or physical experience, and a progressive awareness of its presence. On the other hand, TM involves the easy returning of attention to a mantra (a word or phrase) given to the practitioner by a meditation teacher or instructor. Both of these techniques have been shown to result in a ‘wakeful hypometabolic state of parasympathetic predominance.’2 Accordingly, studies based on these techniques demonstrate a decrease in heart rate, blood pressure, and respiratory rate associated with a predominance of parasympathetic activity. Spiritual practices have varied effects on the autonomic nervous system, endocrine and immune system, and the central nervous system, leading to physiological effects on the cardiovascular system, potentially influencing clinical outcomes. Spiritual practices have varied effects on the autonomic nervous system, endocrine and immune system, and the central nervous system, leading to physiological effects on the cardiovascular system, potentially influencing clinical outcomes. In contrast, meditative techniques of Tantric traditions including Hindu Tantra and Buddhist Vajrayana appear to be associated with an arousal response.3 The various techniques in these traditions involve the cultivation of single-pointed concentration, visualization, use of mantras, and importantly, a spectrum of breathing practices. A given technique often involves a combination of various practices, leading to a state of aroused wakefulness. Hormonal and immunological activity associated with spirituality demonstrate a significant heterogeneity of data. In one meta-analysis of mindfulness practitioners, reductions were observed in NF-kB activity and circulating levels of C-reactive protein, with an increase in CD4+ T cell counts in individuals diagnosed with HIV, and an increase in telomerase activity.4 However, these effects were dose-dependent, and not uniform across the study groups included in the analysis. In various neuroimaging studies, a network of brain regions including frontal lobes, parietal lobes, thalamus, and limbic system are consistently observed to be related to spiritual practices, particularly meditation.1 These data, while demonstrating plausible mechanisms for the potential benefits of spiritual practices, are difficult to generalize due to the wide variety of techniques and methods included in studies. They do, however, provide the framework for appreciating the complexity of prescribing practices such as ‘meditation’ in clinical practice. At the outset, it must be noted that due to the wide variety of practices and experiences included in ‘spirituality,’ there is significant heterogeneity in the data related to CVD outcomes (Figure 3). Additionally, spiritual experiences and behaviours are often self-reported, resulting in potential bias and lack of reproducibility. Spiritual practices influence various aspects of cardiovascular outcomes including all-cause mortality, major adverse cardiac events (such as cardiovascular mortality, non-fatal myocardial infarction, and revascularizations), arrhythmic burden as well as modification of risk factors such as hypertension, blood sugar levels, and inflammatory markers. Spiritual practices influence various aspects of cardiovascular outcomes including all-cause mortality, major adverse cardiac events (such as cardiovascular mortality, non-fatal myocardial infarction, and revascularizations), arrhythmic burden as well as modification of risk factors such as hypertension, blood sugar levels, and inflammatory markers. Infrequent religious attendance is shown to be significantly associated with higher rates of cardiovascular mortality over a follow-up period of 31 years,5 reproduced in the Nurses Health Study that demonstrated a 33% reduction in all-cause mortality among women attending a religious service more than once per week.6 In contrast, religiosity and spirituality were not associated with improved CVD outcomes in the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA) study over 4 years.7 As a secondary prevention measure, TM demonstrated a 48% risk reduction in all-cause mortality during a 5.4-year follow-up with a significant (24%) risk reduction in the composite secondary endpoint including cardiovascular mortality, revascularization, cardiovascular hospitalizations, blood pressure, psychosocial stress factors, and lifestyle behaviours.8 Significant improvements in left ventricular ejection fraction, body mass index, blood glucose, perceived stress, anxiety, and depression have also been demonstrated in comprehensive yoga-based cardiac rehabilitation (CR) that includes the various aspects of traditional yoga such as moral and ethical injunctions, breath regulation, and meditation.9 Atrial fibrillation (AF) has a well-established connection with the ANS, the shortened refractory period being the result of vagal overcompensation arising from increased sympathetic tone. Combined with premature atrial beats, this is thought to result in AF, which is propagated via beta-adrenergic receptor activation. Decreased anxiety and depression scores were associated with a diminished AF burden in patients undergoing 3 months of yoga training.10 While large-scale data are lacking, acute coronary syndromes, sudden cardiac deaths, and other arrhythmic events such as ventricular arrhythmias in those with implantable cardioverter-defibrillators (ICDs) are not infrequently associated with increased psychological stress. Cultivating psychological resilience through spiritual practices can play an important role in mitigating the effects of acute and chronic stress. Although extensive objective data for potential benefits of spirituality on CVD outcomes are lacking, it is an important aspect of clinical practice. Despite the emphasis on evidence-based medicine, clinical practice is replete with the realities of being human, which often defy trial data. No randomized controlled study can answer a distressed patient’s questioning along the lines of ‘Why me?’ or ‘Am I being punished with this disease?’ An individual’s lifestyle is informed not only by the elements of a social history but also their spiritual and religious beliefs, customs, and practices. Acquiring a ‘spiritual history’ may help shed light on unexplored variables of a given patient’s disease process in addition to informing prevention, prognosis, and end-of-life decisions. While spiritual care in medicine is currently mostly limited to palliative care, mental health, and the care of the terminally ill, its inclusion in all areas of medicine may be significant. History-taking in the attributes of spirituality must be emphasized at every level of medical training. Physicians must be trained to relate to various aspects of spirituality in order to connect with patients who may believe it to be an important aspect of healing. Such training must entail the recognition of one’s own bias, and the skilful navigation of a patient’s beliefs without dismissal, rejection, or contempt. Additionally, there is a need for uniformity in assessing the role of spirituality in clinical studies to ensure more reliable and comparable results across studies, while understanding that subjective variability is inevitable. Spirituality is an important aspect of life for many patients affected by CVD. Potential beneficial mechanisms of spirituality include the modulation of the ANS, hormonal, immunological, and neurological pathways. Spiritual practices have been shown to improve outcomes in various cardiovascular disorders such as coronary artery disease, heart failure, and arrhythmias. Training in spiritual history-taking and skilful engagement must be emphasized as an important aspect of the art of medicine. Conflict of interest: none declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chinnaiyan et al. (2021) conducted a review in Cardiovascular disease. Spirituality and meditative practices (e.g., mindfulness, transcendental meditation, yoga, religious attendance) was evaluated on Cardiovascular outcomes (including all-cause mortality, MACE, arrhythmic burden, and cardiovascular risk factors). Spiritual practices such as transcendental meditation and frequent religious attendance may improve cardiovascular outcomes.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: