Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Photochemical mechanisms are core components of air quality models, yet differences among them can introduce substantial uncertainty in tropospheric ozone (O 3 ) simulations. We compared three mechanisms (CB06, SAPRC07, and RACM2) using CMAQ during an O 3 pollution episode in Chengdu, China. A customized volatile organic compound (VOC) emission inventory was developed for RACM2. RACM2 and SAPRC07 produced comparable O 3 levels (94.8–96.1 ppbv) with better performance at high-NO x urban site, whereas CB06 simulated lower O 3 (∼80 ppbv) and performed better at low-NO x site. Inter-mechanistic differences in O 3 formation were mainly associated with RO 2 +NO reactions, consistent with larger variability in RO 2 than in HO 2 , while O 3 loss differences mainly arose from OH+NO 2 and O 3 +alkene reactions. Differences in primary RO x production were most evident in carbonyl photolysis, whereas termination differences mainly involved RONO 2 formation and peroxy-radical self- and cross-reactions. Mechanism-dependent discrepancies were more pronounced at high-NO x urban site. Despite these discrepancies, the three mechanisms exhibited a broadly consistent photochemical framework, with O 3 formation dominated by RO 2 +NO and RO x termination shifting from NO x -dependent pathways at high-NO x urban site toward peroxy-radical reactions at low-NO x suburban site. Sensitivity analysis showed O 3 was most sensitive to anthropogenic aromatics and alkenes at urban site and relatively more sensitive to biogenic VOCs at suburban site, although response magnitudes remained mechanism dependent. These findings demonstrate that mechanism choice substantially affects O 3 formation and precursor sensitivities, emphasizing the need for multi-mechanism approaches to improve model reliability and support emission control strategies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Liu et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: