Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Many public transport networks publish real-time vehicle positions but not delays, and many timetables give intermediate stop times interpolated at constant speed rather than observed. Bizkaibus, the interurban bus network of Biscay (Spain), has both properties: after the first hour of a trip, 85% of buses pass a stop more than two minutes before the published time. This paper specifies the arrival prediction method of the Bizkaibus+ app (Bide+) in enough detail to reimplement it in any language. The method uses timetable differences instead of absolute times; learns the actual travel time between consecutive stops by time band, as a median shrunk towards the all-day median of the segment; and predicts from three layers with explicit abstention rules: the GPS position projected onto the route, the last stop registered by the feed, and the timetable corrected trip by trip. It recalibrates itself daily, adopting only changes that reduce the error on held-out data. In 9.1 million predictions over 23 days, checked against the actual passage, the arrival shown is within ±2 minutes in 92–96% of cases when the bus is less than three minutes away and in 67% at ten to twenty minutes, against 23–25% for the published timetable. Without any live data, the corrected timetable alone doubles the accuracy of the published one. Files: the preprint (PDF) and an archive with the Python reference implementation, test vectors with 407 checks produced by the production engine, the public evaluator, the learned tables and the evaluation data. Code under the MIT licence; text and data under CC BY 4.0. Preprint, not peer reviewed. A longer technical report in Spanish is available at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24041572.Version 1.1 corrects version 1.0 after peer review by independent reviewers: it states the exceptions to temporal validation in the day-by-day evaluation, reports that a neural network using the same information improves on the method by 3–7% (the method is kept for auditability, not for accuracy), clarifies that the reference passage is not independent of layer 2, qualifies several figures (52% of all observed passages, 38% instead of 40%, the 97.8% of likely-departed trips), states which results cannot yet be recomputed from public data, and fixes the appendix numbering and several references. No result changes.The code and data archive (reference implementation, test vectors, evaluator, learned tables and evaluation data) is unchanged from version 1.0 and is available in that version of this record: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24285541
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yeray Garrido (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: