Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study compared data loss, within-system reliability, and between-system agreement of marker-based (Vicon) and markerless (Theia3D) motion capture during back squats. Twenty-nine powerlifters (10 female, 19 male) performed barbell back squats at 70% 1RM with simultaneous motion capture. Data loss, reliability (intraclass correlation coefficient, standard error of measurement, coefficient of variation and minimal detectable change [MDC]) and agreement (concordance correlation coefficient [CCC], Bland-Altman, statistical parametric mapping) were assessed for hip, knee, ankle, trunk and stance parameters. Theia3D demonstrated substantially less data loss than Vicon (0.7% vs. 13.0%), with ankle dorsiflexion and trunk inclination particularly problematic for marker-based tracking. Within-system reliability was similar or superior for Theia3D compared to Vicon (MDC = 3.32-5.97° vs. 4.11-13.60°). However, between-system agreement was generally poor (CCC < 0.900 for most variables), with Vicon estimating larger lower-limb flexion angles and exhibiting largest disagreement at the hip joint. While Theia3D offers practical advantages (superior data completeness and measurement precision, portability, lower cost) for deep squat assessment, poor between-system agreement indicates these systems should not be used interchangeably. However, results may not transfer across movement tasks, study populations, practical setups and system selection should therefore align with study-specific priorities, available resources and expertise.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Amdi et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: