Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Migration is widely recognized as a strategy for animals to track seasonally shifting resources. Yet, seasonal and spatial dynamics of migration are challenging to study, particularly for difficult‐to‐track insects. Among insects, monarch butterflies Danaus plexippus have a well‐documented fall migration, but spring breeding recolonization remains poorly understood, particularly in the western United States. We conducted multi‐year surveys across six regions in the western breeding range to characterize monarch breeding phenology and evaluate three related hypotheses and associated predictions: 1) the successive broods model, with discrete generations shifting activity across the breeding range, 2) a diffusion‐like expansion model with overlapping breeding periods, and 3) a mid‐summer lull model with temporary summer declines in breeding areas near the overwintering habitat. Immature monarch presence served as an indicator of breeding activity. Our results are inconsistent with the predictions for both the sequential generational replacement of successive broods and a mid‐summer lull. Breeding onset occurred earlier near overwintering areas and gradually expanded north‐ and eastward, with sustained activity in many regions throughout the season. Termination of breeding occurred earlier at more distant sites, resulting in longer breeding activity nearer to overwintering habitat. Immature monarch density declined with distance from overwintering areas at onset and termination, suggesting delayed colonization of peripheral regions. Together, these results are consistent with a diffusion‐like expansion of breeding. Furthermore, western monarchs did not appear to initiate or terminate breeding in close synchrony with host plant availability. These findings highlight differences between western monarch breeding dynamics and paradigms for eastern monarchs, suggesting that a species can employ distinct spatial strategies for recolonizing its breeding range in different regions. More generally, these results distinguish insect migration from systems with direct movement between wintering and breeding habitats, and underscore the value of multi‐year, landscape‐scale monitoring for resolving habitat use across heterogeneous environments.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Diethelm et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: