Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Since the turn of the century, civil society organizations (CSOs) worldwide have faced the ‘shrinking of civic space’. While this backlash against civic freedoms was once considered primarily relevant to hybrid regimes and electoral autocracies, it has increasingly manifested in established Western democracies, including Germany. This paper examines how restrictions on civic space emerge in the German non-profit sector, and the sources of organizational resilience that enable CSOs to withstand these pressures. The study analyses four distinct types of restrictions: legal and administrative restrictions; discursive delegitimization; criminalization and judicial coercion; and extra-legal pressures. These types of restriction are examined across three sectors that represent theoretically contrasting profiles: social work organizations; civil protection and disaster management; and internationally active solidarity organizations. The paper empirically combines descriptive statistical analysis of ZiviZ-Survey 2023 microdata with a review of legal, political and media developments from 2019 to 2026. The findings reveal that shrinking civic space in Germany occurs less through overt legal repression than through the gradual accumulation of administrative uncertainty, funding insecurity, and discursive delegitimization. Resilience is not a generic organizational characteristic, but rather a sector-specific configuration shaped by each sector’s structural position vis-àvis the state. Civil protection benefits from dense networks and institutional embeddedness, social work benefits from professional capacity and federative coordination, and international solidarity benefits from organizational autonomy and funding diversification. These findings have implications for adapting civil society support strategies to democratic contexts in which civic space restriction operates through subtler procedural mechanisms.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rebecca Wagner (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: