Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Metagenomic next-generation sequencing offers a powerful approach for broadly detecting known and emerging pathogens and is being applied to an expanding set of applications from infectious disease diagnostics to biodefense. However, the ability to sequence a sample of interest does not necessarily mean that the results will be actionable for decision-makers. Generalizable, data-driven approaches are needed to quantify the performance of metagenomic workflows and enable high-confidence decision-making. Here, we generate a well-characterized matrix of experimental samples, parameterizing variables such as biological target type and quantity, background composition and complexity, and processing workflow methodology. We systematically characterize the impact these variables have on the sensitivity and specificity of target detection and benchmark performance against a gold-standard method, polymerase chain reaction. We show that the target mass fraction (the fraction of the total nucleic acid mass contributed by a target’s genome) is a key determinant for signal detection, and we develop a generalizable linear mixed effects model that can be used to estimate sequencing depth requirements based on input properties. Given adequate sequencing depth, sensitivity is driven by the quantity of the target detected in the background (e.g., the Limit of Blank). We also investigate the impact that closely related organisms can have on the specificity of target detection due to mis-assignment of reads originating from shared genomic regions, especially as the ratio of target to near-neighbors decreases. Our results demonstrate that detection performance varies based on sample type, target, methodology, and use case, complicating comparison and interpretation. We therefore propose and exercise a synthetic data generation and analysis approach to quantitatively assess the sensitivity and specificity of target detection given a particular workflow, target, and sample type of interest. Collectively, our study seeks to provide insights for generalizable, data-driven approaches to characterize, optimize, and refine metagenomic workflows to enable actionable decision making.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mallek et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: