Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
I compare two sessions of Galactic neutral-hydrogen 21-cm observations made with the SALSA radio telescope at Onsala with position-matched spectra derived from a reduced, spatially smoothed HI4PI cube. The sample comprises 40 SALSA records at 31 distinct pointings. A focused north south comparison uses six latitude-matched pairs at three Galactic longitudes in two selected negative-velocity intervals. The median north-minus-south emission-weighted velocity contrasts have opposite signs in the two intervals: +3.22 and −3.18 km s−1 in SALSA, and +3.13 and −4.24 km s−1 in the smoothed HI4PI-derived profiles. The spectra also show position-dependent line-width and percentile-shape differences, including median SALSA central-80-per-cent width contrasts of −2.39 and −0.63 km s−1. A comparison with published prominent H I self-absorption structures finds catalogue overlap with the middle negative-velocity interval; however, adding a catalogue-centred absorption template does not improve held-out spectral residuals. These results provide a reproducible, localised description of broad-beam spectral asymmetries and a documented negative test of one cold-gas explanation. Spatially correlated sightlines, approximate temperature calibration, smoothing, and exploratory velocity-window selection limit the interpretation. I do not infer a unique Galactic streaming mechanism or claim a new discovery of H I self-absorption.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
begüm yıldırım (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: